Skip to content

Chapter 6: Chapter IV. Simplest Cases

NOW let us see how, on first principles, we can differentiate some simple algebraical expression.

Case 1.

Let us begin with the simple expression y equals x squared. Now remember that the fundamental notion about the calculus is the idea of growing. Mathematicians call it varying. Now as y and x squared are equal to one another, it is clear that if x grows, x squared will also grow. And if x squared grows, then y will also grow. What we have got to find out is the proportion between the growing of y and the growing of x. In other words our task is to find out the ratio between d y and d x, or, in brief, to find the value of StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction.

Let x, then, grow a little bit bigger and become x plus d x; similarly, y will grow a bit bigger and will become y plus d y. Then, clearly, it will still be true that the enlarged y will be equal to the square of the enlarged x. Writing this down, we have: y plus d y equals left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis squared period

Doing the squaring we get: y plus d y equals x squared plus 2 x dot d x plus left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared period

What does left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared mean? Remember that d x meant a bit-a little bit-of x. Then left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared will mean a little bit of a little bit of x; that is, as explained above (p. 4), it is a small quantity of the second order of smallness. It may therefore be discarded as quite inconsiderable in comparison with the other terms. Leaving it out, we then have: y plus d y equals x squared plus 2 x dot d x period

Now y equals x squared; so let us subtract this from the equation and we have left d y equals 2 x dot d x

Dividing across by d x, we find StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals 2 x period

Now this[3] is what we set out to find. The ratio of the growing of y to the growing of x is, in the case before us, found to be 2 x.

Numerical example.

Suppose x equals 100 and therefore y equals 10 comma 000. Then let x grow till it becomes 101 (that is, let d x equals 1 ). Then the enlarged y will be 101 times 101 equals 10,201. But if we agree that we may ignore small quantities of the second order, 1 may be rejected as compared with 10,000; so we may round off the enlarged y to 10,200. y has grown from 10,000 to 10,200; the bit added on is d y, which is therefore 200.

StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals StartFraction 200 Over 1 EndFraction equals 200. According to the algebra-working of the previous paragraph, we find StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals 2 x. And so it is; for x equals 100 and 2 x equals 200.

But, you will say, we neglected a whole unit.

Well, try again, making d x a still smaller bit.

Try d x equals one tenth. Then x plus d x equals 100.1, and left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis squared equals 100.1 times 100.1 equals 10 comma 020.01 period

Now the last figure 1 is only one-millionth part of the 10,000, and is utterly negligible; so we may take 10,020 without the little decimal at the end.

And this makes d y equals 20; and StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals StartFraction 20 Over 0.1 EndFraction equals 200, which is still the same as 2 x.

Case 2.

Try differentiating y equals x cubed in the same way.

We let y grow to y plus d y, while x grows to x plus d x.

Then we have y plus d y equals left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis cubed period

Doing the cubing we obtain y plus d y equals x cubed plus 3 x squared dot d x plus 3 x left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared plus left parenthesis d x right parenthesis cubed period

Now we know that we may neglect small quantities of the second and third orders; since, when d y and d x are both made indefinitely small, left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared and left parenthesis d x right parenthesis cubed will become indefinitely smaller by comparison. So, regarding them as negligible, we have left: y plus d y equals x cubed plus 3 x squared dot d x period

But y equals x cubed; and, subtracting this, we have: StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column d y 2nd Column equals 3 x squared dot d x comma 2nd Row 1st Column and StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals 3 x squared period EndLayout

Case 3.

Try differentiating y equals x Superscript 4. Starting as before by letting both y and x grow a bit, we have: y plus d y equals left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis Superscript 4 Baseline period

Working out the raising to the fourth power, we get y plus d y equals x Superscript 4 Baseline plus 4 x cubed d x plus 6 x squared left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared plus 4 x left parenthesis d x right parenthesis cubed plus left parenthesis d x right parenthesis Superscript 4 Baseline period

Then striking out the terms containing all the higher powers of d x, as being negligible by comparison, we have y plus d y equals x Superscript 4 Baseline plus 4 x cubed d x period

Subtracting the original y equals x Superscript 4, we have left StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column d y 2nd Column equals 4 x cubed d x comma 2nd Row 1st Column and StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals 4 x cubed period EndLayout

Now all these cases are quite easy. Let us collect the results to see if we can infer any general rule. Put them in two columns, the values of y in one and the corresponding values found for StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction in the other: thus

y StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction
x squared 2 x
x cubed 3 x squared
x Superscript 4 4 x cubed

Just look at these results: the operation of differentiating appears to have had the effect of diminishing the power of x by 1 (for example in the last case reducing x Superscript 4 to x cubed), and at the same time multiplying by a number (the same number in fact which originally appeared as the power). Now, when you have once seen this, you might easily conjecture how the others will run. You would expect that differentiating x Superscript 5 would give 5 x Superscript 4, or differentiating x Superscript 6 would give 6 x Superscript 5. If you hesitate, try one of these, and see whether the conjecture comes right.

Try y equals x Superscript 5.

Then StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column y plus d y 2nd Column equals left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis Superscript 5 Baseline 2nd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals x Superscript 5 Baseline plus 5 x Superscript 4 Baseline d x plus 10 x cubed left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared plus 10 x squared left parenthesis d x right parenthesis cubed 3rd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column plus 5 x left parenthesis d x right parenthesis Superscript 4 Baseline plus left parenthesis d x right parenthesis Superscript 5 Baseline period EndLayout

Neglecting all the terms containing small quantities of the higher orders, we have left StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column y plus d y 2nd Column equals x Superscript 5 Baseline plus 5 x Superscript 4 Baseline d x comma 2nd Row 1st Column and subtracting y 2nd Column equals x Superscript 5 Baseline leaves us 3rd Row 1st Column d y 2nd Column equals 5 x Superscript 4 Baseline d x comma 4th Row 1st Column whence StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals 5 x Superscript 4 Baseline comma exactly as we supposed period EndLayout

Following out logically our observation, we should conclude that if we want to deal with any higher power,—call it n—we could tackle it in the same way.

Let y equals x Superscript n,

then we should expect to find that StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals n x Superscript n minus 1 Baseline period

For example, let n equals 8, then y equals x Superscript 8; and differentiating it would give StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals 8 x Superscript 7.

And, indeed, the rule that differentiating x Superscript n gives as the result n x Superscript n minus 1 is true for all cases where n is a whole number and positive. [Expanding left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis Superscript n by the binomial theorem will at once show this.] But the question whether it is true for cases where n has negative or fractional values requires further consideration.

Case of a negative power.

Let y equals x Superscript negative 2. Then proceed as before: StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column y plus d y 2nd Column equals left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis Superscript negative 2 Baseline 2nd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals x Superscript negative 2 Baseline left parenthesis 1 plus StartFraction d x Over x EndFraction right parenthesis Superscript negative 2 Baseline period EndLayout

Expanding this by the binomial theorem (see p. 137), we get StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals x Superscript negative 2 Baseline left bracket 1 minus StartFraction 2 d x Over x EndFraction plus StartFraction 2 left parenthesis 2 plus 1 right parenthesis Over 1 times 2 EndFraction left parenthesis StartFraction d x Over x EndFraction right parenthesis squared minus etc period right bracket 2nd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals x Superscript negative 2 Baseline minus 2 x Superscript negative 3 Baseline dot d x plus 3 x Superscript negative 4 Baseline left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared minus 4 x Superscript negative 5 Baseline left parenthesis d x right parenthesis cubed plus etc period EndLayout

So, neglecting the small quantities of higher orders of smallness, we have: y plus d y equals x Superscript negative 2 Baseline minus 2 x Superscript negative 3 Baseline dot d x period Subtracting the original y equals x Superscript negative 2, we find StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column d y 2nd Column equals minus 2 x Superscript negative 3 Baseline d x comma 2nd Row 1st Column StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals minus 2 x Superscript negative 3 Baseline period EndLayout And this is still in accordance with the rule inferred above.

Case of a fractional power.

Let y equals x Superscript one half. Then, as before, StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column y plus d y equals left parenthesis x plus d x right parenthesis Superscript one half Baseline equals x Superscript one half Baseline left parenthesis 1 plus StartFraction d x Over x EndFraction right parenthesis Superscript one half Baseline 2nd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals StartRoot x EndRoot plus one half StartFraction d x Over StartRoot x EndRoot EndFraction minus one eighth StartFraction left parenthesis d x right parenthesis squared Over x StartRoot x EndRoot EndFraction plus terms with higher 3rd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column powers of d x period EndLayout

Subtracting the original y equals x Superscript one half, and neglecting higher powers we have left: d y equals one half StartFraction d x Over StartRoot x EndRoot EndFraction equals one half x Superscript negative one half Baseline dot d x comma and StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals one half x Superscript negative one half. Agreeing with the general rule.

Summary. Let us see how far we have got. We have arrived at the following rule: To differentiate x Superscript n, multiply by the power and reduce the power by one, so giving us n x Superscript n minus 1 as the result.

Exercises I. (See p. 252 for Answers.)

Differentiate the following:

(1) y equals x Superscript 13

(2) y equals x Superscript negative three halves

(3) y equals x Superscript 2 a

(4) u equals t Superscript 2.4

(5) z equals RootIndex 3 StartRoot u EndRoot

(6) y equals StartRoot x Superscript negative 5 Baseline EndRoot

(7) u equals RootIndex 5 StartRoot StartFraction 1 Over x Superscript 8 Baseline EndFraction EndRoot

(8) y equals 2 x Superscript a

(9) y equals RootIndex q StartRoot x cubed EndRoot

(10) y equals RootIndex n StartRoot StartFraction 1 Over x Superscript m Baseline EndFraction EndRoot

You have now learned how to differentiate powers of x. How easy it is!

6.1 Footnotes:

[3] N.B.—This ratio StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction is the result of differentiating y with respect to x. Differentiating means finding the differential coefficient. Suppose we had some other function of x, as, for example, u equals 7 x squared plus 3. Then if we were told to differentiate this with respect to x, we should have to find StartFraction d u Over d x EndFraction, or, what is the same thing, StartFraction d left parenthesis 7 x squared plus 3 right parenthesis Over d x EndFraction. On the other hand, we may have a case in which time was the independent variable (see p. 14), such as this: y equals b plus one half a t squared. Then, if we were told to differentiate it, that means we must find its differential coefficient with respect to t. So that then our business would be to try to find StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction, that is, to find StartFraction d left parenthesis b plus one half a t squared right parenthesis Over d t EndFraction.