Skip to content

Chapter 23: Chapter XXI. Finding Some Solutions

IN this chapter we go to work finding solutions to some important differential equations, using for this purpose the processes shown in the preceding chapters.

The beginner, who now knows how easy most of those processes are in themselves, will here begin to realize that integration is an art. As in all arts, so in this, facility can be acquired only by diligent and regular practice. He who would attain that facility must work out examples, and more examples, and yet more examples, such as are found abundantly in all the regular treatises on the Calculus. Our purpose here must be to afford the briefest introduction to serious work.

Example 1. Find the solution of the differential equation a y plus b StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals 0 period

Transposing we have b StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals minus a y period

Now the mere inspection of this relation tells us that we have got to do with a case in which StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction is proportional to y. If we think of the curve which will represent y as a function of x, it will be such that its slope at any point will be proportional to the ordinate at that point, and will be a negative slope if y is positive. So obviously the curve will be a die-away curve (p. 153), and the solution will contain epsilon Superscript negative x as a factor. But, without presuming on this bit of sagacity, let us go to work.

As both y and d y occur in the equation and on opposite sides, we can do nothing until we get both y and d y to one side, and d x to the other. To do this, we must split our usually inseparable companions d y and d x from one another. StartFraction d y Over y EndFraction equals minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d x period

Having done the deed, we now can see that both sides have got into a shape that is integrable, because we recognize StartFraction d y Over y EndFraction, or StartFraction 1 Over y EndFraction d y, as a differential that we have met with (p. 143) when differentiating logarithms. So we may at once write down the instructions to integrate, integral StartFraction d y Over y EndFraction equals integral minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d x semicolon and doing the two integrations, we have: log Subscript epsilon Baseline y equals minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x plus log Subscript epsilon Baseline upper C comma where log Subscript epsilon Baseline upper C is the yet undetermined constant[8] of integration. Then, delogarizing, we get: y equals upper C epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x Baseline comma which is the solution required. Now, this solution looks quite unlike the original differential equation from which it was constructed: yet to an expert mathematician they both convey the same information as to the way in which y depends on x.

Now, as to the upper C, its meaning depends on the initial value of y. For if we put x equals 0 in order to see what value y then has, we find that this makes y equals upper C epsilon Superscript negative 0; and as epsilon Superscript negative 0 Baseline equals 1 we see that upper C is nothing else than the particular value[9] of y at starting. This we may call y 0, and so write the solution as y equals y 0 epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x Baseline period

Example 2.

Let us take as an example to solve a y plus b StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals g comma where g is a constant. Again, inspecting the equation will suggest, (1) that somehow or other epsilon Superscript x will come into the solution, and (2) that if at any part of the curve y becomes either a maximum or a minimum, so that StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals 0, then y will have the value equals StartFraction g Over a EndFraction. But let us go to work as before, separating the differentials and trying to transform the thing into some integrable shape.

StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column b StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals g minus a y semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals StartFraction a Over b EndFraction left parenthesis StartFraction g Over a EndFraction minus y right parenthesis semicolon 3rd Row 1st Column StartStartFraction d y OverOver y minus StartFraction g Over a EndFraction EndEndFraction 2nd Column equals minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d x period EndLayout
StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column b StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals g minus a y semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals StartFraction a Over b EndFraction left parenthesis StartFraction g Over a EndFraction minus y right parenthesis semicolon 3rd Row 1st Column StartStartFraction d y OverOver y minus StartFraction g Over a EndFraction EndEndFraction 2nd Column equals minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d x period EndLayout

Now we have done our best to get nothing but y and d y on one side, and nothing but d x on the other. But is the result on the left side integrable?

It is of the same form as the result on p. 145; so, writing the instructions to integrate, we have: integral StartStartFraction d y OverOver y minus StartFraction g Over a EndFraction EndEndFraction equals minus integral StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d x semicolon and, doing the integration, and adding the appropriate constant, log Subscript epsilon Baseline left parenthesis y minus StartFraction g Over a EndFraction right parenthesis equals minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x plus log Subscript epsilon Baseline upper C semicolon and finally, StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column whence y minus StartFraction g Over a EndFraction 2nd Column equals upper C epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x Baseline semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column y 2nd Column equals StartFraction g Over a EndFraction plus upper C epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x Baseline comma EndLayout which is the solution.

If the condition is laid down that y equals 0 when x equals 0 we can find upper C; for then the exponential becomes equals 1; and we have StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column 0 2nd Column equals StartFraction g Over a EndFraction plus upper C comma 2nd Row 1st Column or upper C 2nd Column equals minus StartFraction g Over a EndFraction period EndLayout

Putting in this value, the solution becomes y equals StartFraction g Over a EndFraction left parenthesis 1 minus epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x Baseline right parenthesis period

But further, if x grows indefinitely, y will grow to a maximum; for when x equals normal infinity, the exponential equals 0, giving y Subscript max period Baseline equals StartFraction g Over a EndFraction. Substituting this, we get finally y equals y Subscript max period Baseline left parenthesis 1 minus epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction x Baseline right parenthesis period

This result is also of importance in physical science.

Example 3.

Let a y plus b StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction equals g dot sine 2 pi n t period

We shall find this much less tractable than the preceding. First divide through by b. StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction plus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction y equals StartFraction g Over b EndFraction sine 2 pi n t period

Now, as it stands, the left side is not integrable. But it can be made so by the artifice - and this is where skill and practice suggest a plan-of multiplying all the terms by epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t, giving us: StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline plus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction y epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline equals StartFraction g Over b EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t comma which is the same as StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline plus y StartFraction d left parenthesis epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline right parenthesis Over d t EndFraction equals StartFraction g Over b EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t semicolon and this being a perfect differential may be integrated thus:-since, if u equals y epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline comma StartFraction d u Over d t EndFraction equals StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline plus y StartFraction d left parenthesis epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline right parenthesis Over d t EndFraction, StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column y epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t 2nd Column equals StartFraction g Over b EndFraction integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t dot d t plus upper C comma 2nd Row 1st Column or y 2nd Column equals StartFraction g Over b EndFraction epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t dot d t plus upper C epsilon Superscript minus StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline period left bracket upper A right bracket EndLayout

The last term is obviously a term which will die out as t increases, and may be omitted. The trouble now comes in to find the integral that appears as a factor. To tackle this we resort to the device (see p. 224) of integration by parts, the general formula for which is integral u d v equals u v minus integral v d u. For this purpose write StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row 1st Column u 2nd Column equals epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column d v 2nd Column equals sine 2 pi n t dot d t period EndLayout

We shall then have StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row 1st Column d u 2nd Column equals epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline times StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d t semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column v 2nd Column equals minus StartFraction 1 Over 2 pi n EndFraction cosine 2 pi n t period EndLayout

Inserting these, the integral in question becomes: StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t dot 2nd Column sine 2 pi n t dot d t 2nd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals minus StartFraction 1 Over 2 pi n EndFraction dot epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot cosine 2 pi n t minus integral minus StartFraction 1 Over 2 pi n EndFraction cosine 2 pi n t dot epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot StartFraction a Over b EndFraction d t 3rd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals minus StartFraction 1 Over 2 pi n EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline cosine 2 pi n t plus StartFraction a Over 2 pi n b EndFraction integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot cosine 2 pi n t dot d t period 3rd Column left bracket upper B right bracket EndLayout

The last integral is still irreducible. To evade the difficulty, repeat the integration by parts of the left side, but treating it in the reverse way by writing: StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row 1st Column u 2nd Column equals sine 2 pi n t semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column d v 2nd Column equals epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot d t semicolon EndLayout 2nd Row 1st Column whence 2nd Column StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row 1st Column d u 2nd Column equals 2 pi n dot cosine 2 pi n t dot d t semicolon 2nd Row 1st Column v 2nd Column equals StartFraction b Over a EndFraction epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t EndLayout EndLayout

Inserting these, we get StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t dot d t 2nd Row 1st Column Blank 2nd Column equals StartFraction b Over a EndFraction dot epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t minus StartFraction 2 pi n b Over a EndFraction integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot cosine 2 pi n t dot d t period left bracket upper C right bracket EndLayout

Noting that the final intractable integral in [C] is the same as that in left bracket normal upper B right bracket, we may eliminate it, by multiplying left bracket normal upper B right bracket by StartFraction 2 pi n b Over a EndFraction, and multiplying [c] by StartFraction a Over 2 pi n b EndFraction, and adding them.

The result, when cleared down, is: StartLayout 1st Row integral epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline dot sine 2 pi n t dot d t equals epsilon Superscript StartFraction a Over b EndFraction t Baseline left brace StartFraction a b dot sine 2 pi n t minus 2 pi n b squared dot cosine 2 pi n t Over a squared plus 4 pi squared n squared b squared EndFraction right brace left bracket upper D right bracket EndLayout

Inserting this value in left bracket normal upper A right bracket, we get y equals g left brace StartFraction a dot sine 2 pi n t minus 2 pi n b dot cosine 2 pi n t Over a squared plus 4 pi squared n squared b squared EndFraction right brace period

To simplify still further, let us imagine an angle phi such that tangent phi equals StartFraction 2 pi n b Over a EndFraction.

Then sine phi equals StartFraction 2 pi n b Over StartRoot a squared plus 4 pi squared n squared b squared EndRoot EndFraction comma and cosine phi equals StartFraction a Over StartRoot a squared plus 4 pi squared n squared b squared EndRoot EndFraction period

Substituting these, we get: y equals g StartFraction cosine phi dot sine 2 pi n t minus sine phi dot cosine 2 pi n t Over StartRoot a squared plus 4 pi squared n squared b squared EndRoot EndFraction comma which may be written y equals g StartFraction sine left parenthesis 2 pi n t minus phi right parenthesis Over StartRoot a squared plus 4 pi squared n squared b squared EndRoot EndFraction comma which is the solution desired.

This is indeed none other than the equation of an alternating electric current, where g represents the amplitude of the electromotive force, n the frequency, a the resistance, b the coefficient of self-induction of the circuit, and phi is an angle of lag.

Example 4.

Suppose that upper M d x plus upper N d y equals 0.

We could integrate this expression directly, if upper M were a function of x only, and upper N a function of y only; but, if both upper M and upper N are functions that depend on both x and y, how are we to integrate it? Is it itself an exact differential? That is: have upper M and upper N each been formed by partial differentiation from some common function upper U, or not? If they have, then StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row StartFraction partial differential upper U Over partial differential x EndFraction equals upper M comma 2nd Row StartFraction partial differential upper U Over partial differential y EndFraction equals upper N period EndLayout And if such a common function exists, then StartFraction partial differential upper U Over partial differential x EndFraction d x plus StartFraction partial differential upper U Over partial differential y EndFraction d y is an exact differential (compare p. 172).

Now the test of the matter is this. If the expression is an exact differential, it must be true that StartLayout 1st Row StartFraction d upper M Over d y EndFraction equals StartFraction d upper N Over d x EndFraction semicolon 2nd Row for then StartFraction d left parenthesis d upper U right parenthesis Over d x d y EndFraction equals StartFraction d left parenthesis d upper U right parenthesis Over d y d x EndFraction comma EndLayout which is necessarily true.

Take as an illustration the equation left parenthesis 1 plus 3 x y right parenthesis d x plus x squared d y equals 0 period

Is this an exact differential or not? Apply the test. StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row 1st Column StartFraction d left parenthesis 1 plus 3 x y right parenthesis Over d y EndFraction 2nd Column equals 3 x comma 2nd Row 1st Column StartFraction d left parenthesis x squared right parenthesis Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals 2 x comma EndLayout which do not agree. Therefore, it is not an exact differential, and the two functions 1 plus 3 x y and x squared have not come from a common original function.

It is possible in such cases to discover, however, an integrating factor, that is to say, a factor such that if both are multiplied by this factor, the expression will become an exact differential. There is no one rule for discovering such an integrating factor; but experience will usually suggest one. In the present instance 2 x will act as such. Multiplying by 2 x, we get left parenthesis 2 x plus 6 x squared y right parenthesis d x plus 2 x cubed d y equals 0 period

Now apply the test to this. StartLayout Enlarged left brace 1st Row 1st Column StartFraction d left parenthesis 2 x plus 6 x squared y right parenthesis Over d y EndFraction 2nd Column equals 6 x squared comma 2nd Row 1st Column StartFraction d left parenthesis 2 x cubed right parenthesis Over d x EndFraction 2nd Column equals 6 x squared comma EndLayout which agrees. Hence this is an exact differential, and may be integrated. Now, if w equals 2 x cubed y, d w equals 6 x squared y d x plus 2 x cubed d y period

Hence integral 6 x squared y d x plus integral 2 x cubed d y equals w equals 2 x cubed y semicolon so that we get upper U equals x squared plus 2 x cubed y plus upper C period

Example 5. Let StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction plus n squared y equals 0.

In this case we have a differential equation of the second degree, in which y appears in the form of a second differential coefficient, as well as in person.

Transposing, we have StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction equals minus n squared y.

It appears from this that we have to do with a function such that its second differential coefficient is proportional to itself, but with reversed sign. In Chapter XV, we found that there was such a function-namely, the sine (or the cosine also) which possessed this property. So, without further ado, we may infer that the solution will be of the form y equals upper A sine left parenthesis p t plus q right parenthesis. However, let us go to work.

Multiply both sides of the original equation by 2 StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction and integrate, giving us 2 StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction plus 2 x squared y StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction equals 0, and, as 2 StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction equals StartFraction d left parenthesis StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction right parenthesis squared Over d t EndFraction comma left parenthesis StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction right parenthesis squared plus n squared left parenthesis y squared minus upper C squared right parenthesis equals 0 comma upper C being a constant. Then, taking the square roots, StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction equals minus n StartRoot y squared minus upper C squared EndRoot and StartFraction d y Over StartRoot upper C squared minus y squared EndRoot EndFraction equals n dot d t period

But it can be shown that (see p. 168) StartFraction 1 Over StartRoot upper C squared minus y squared EndRoot EndFraction equals StartStartFraction d left parenthesis arc sine StartFraction y Over upper C EndFraction right parenthesis OverOver d y EndEndFraction semicolon whence, passing from angles to sines, arc sine StartFraction y Over upper C EndFraction equals n t plus upper C 1 and y equals upper C sine left parenthesis n t plus upper C 1 right parenthesis comma where upper C 1 is a constant angle that comes in by integration.

Or, preferably, this may be written y equals upper A sine n t plus upper B cosine n t comma which is the solution period

Example 6. StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction minus n squared y equals 0.

Here we have obviously to deal with a function y which is such that its second differential coefficient is proportional to itself. The only function we know that has this property is the exponential function (see p. 139), and we may be certain therefore that the solution of the equation will be of that form.

Proceeding as before, by multiplying through by 2 StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction, and integrating, we get 2 StartFraction d squared y Over d x squared EndFraction StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction minus 2 x squared y StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals 0, and, as 2 StartFraction d squared y Over d x squared EndFraction StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction equals StartFraction d left parenthesis StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction right parenthesis squared Over d x EndFraction comma left parenthesis StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction right parenthesis squared minus n squared left parenthesis y squared plus c squared right parenthesis equals 0, StartFraction d y Over d x EndFraction minus n StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot equals 0 comma where c is a constant, and StartFraction d y Over StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot EndFraction equals n d x.

Now, if w equals log Subscript epsilon Baseline left parenthesis y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot right parenthesis equals log Subscript epsilon Baseline u, StartFraction d w Over d u EndFraction equals StartFraction 1 Over u EndFraction comma StartFraction d u Over d y EndFraction equals 1 plus StartFraction y Over StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot EndFraction equals StartFraction y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot Over StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot EndFraction and StartFraction d w Over d y EndFraction equals StartFraction 1 Over StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot EndFraction period

Hence, integrating, this gives us StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column log Subscript epsilon Baseline left parenthesis y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot right parenthesis 2nd Column equals n x plus log Subscript epsilon Baseline upper C comma 2nd Row 1st Column y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot 2nd Column equals upper C epsilon Superscript n x Baseline period 3rd Column left parenthesis 1 right parenthesis EndLayout

Now left parenthesis y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot right parenthesis times left parenthesis negative y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot right parenthesis equals c squared semicolon whence StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column negative y plus StartRoot y squared plus c squared EndRoot equals StartFraction c squared Over upper C EndFraction epsilon Superscript minus n x Baseline period 2nd Column left parenthesis 2 right parenthesis EndLayout

Subtracting (2) from (1) and dividing by 2, we then have y equals one half upper C epsilon Superscript n x Baseline minus one half StartFraction c squared Over upper C EndFraction epsilon Superscript minus n x Baseline comma which is more conveniently written y equals upper A epsilon Superscript n x Baseline plus upper B epsilon Superscript minus n x Baseline period Or, the solution, which at first sight does not look as if it had anything to do with the original equation, shows that y consists of two terms, one of which grows logarithmically as x increases, and of a second term which dies away as x increases.

Example 7.

Let b StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction plus a StartFraction d y Over d t EndFraction plus g y equals 0 period

Examination of this expression will show that, if b equals 0, it has the form of Example 1, the solution of which was a negative exponential. On the other hand, if a equals 0, its form becomes the same as that of Example 6, the solution of which is the sum of a positive and a negative exponential. It is therefore not very surprising to find that the solution of the present example is StartLayout 1st Row 1st Column y 2nd Column equals left parenthesis epsilon Superscript minus m t Baseline right parenthesis left parenthesis upper A epsilon Superscript n t Baseline plus upper B epsilon Superscript minus n t Baseline right parenthesis comma 2nd Row 1st Column where m 2nd Column equals StartFraction a Over 2 b EndFraction and n equals StartRoot StartFraction a squared Over 4 b squared EndFraction EndRoot minus StartFraction g Over b EndFraction period EndLayout

The steps by which this solution is reached are not given here; they may be found in advanced treatises.

Example 8.

StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction equals a squared StartFraction d squared y Over d x squared EndFraction period
StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction equals a squared StartFraction d squared y Over d x squared EndFraction period

It was seen (p. 174) that this equation was derived from the original y equals upper F left parenthesis x plus a t right parenthesis plus f left parenthesis x minus a t right parenthesis comma where upper F and f were any arbitrary functions of t.

Another way of dealing with it is to transform it by a change of variables into StartFraction d squared y Over d u dot d v EndFraction equals 0 comma where u equals x plus a t, and v equals x minus a t, leading to the same general solution. If we consider a case in which upper F vanishes, then we have simply y equals f left parenthesis x minus a t right parenthesis semicolon and this merely states that, at the time t equals 0 comma y is a particular function of x, and may be looked upon as denoting that the curve of the relation of y to x has a particular shape. Then any change in the value of t is equivalent simply to an alteration in the origin from which x is reckoned. That is to say, it indicates that, the form of the function being conserved, it is propagated along the x direction with a uniform velocity a; so that whatever the value of the ordinate y at any particular time t 0 at any particular point x 0, the same value of y will appear at the subsequent time t 1 at a point further along, the abscissa of which is x 0 plus a left parenthesis t 1 minus t 0 right parenthesis. In this case the simplified equation represents the propagation of a wave (of any form) at a uniform speed along the x direction.

If the differential equation had been written m StartFraction d squared y Over d t squared EndFraction equals k StartFraction d squared y Over d x squared EndFraction comma the solution would have been the same, but the velocity of propagation would have had the value a equals StartRoot StartFraction k Over m EndFraction EndRoot period

You have now been personally conducted over the frontiers into the enchanted land. And in order that you may have a handy reference to the principal results, the author, in bidding you farewell, begs to present you with a passport in the shape of a convenient collection of standard forms (see pp. 249-251). In the middle column are set down a number of the functions which most commonly occur. The results of differentiating them are set down on the left; the results of integrating them are set down on the right. May you find them useful!

23.1 Footnotes:

[8] We may write down any form of constant as the "constant of integration," and the form log Subscript epsilon Baseline upper C is adopted here by preference, because the other terms in this line of equation are, or are treated as logarithms; and it saves complications afterward if the added constant be of the same kind.

[9] Compare what was said about the "constant of integration," with reference to Fig. 48 on p. 184, and Fig. 51 on p. 187.